Opinion | Is ICE a Devil, a Law Enforcement Agency, or America's Secret Police?

2026-04-22 19:00
Residents of Minneapolis take to the streets on January 30, 2026, to protest what they describe as heavy-handed enforcement operations by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). (File photo, AP)
Residents of Minneapolis take to the streets on January 30, 2026, to protest what they describe as heavy-handed enforcement operations by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). (File photo, AP)

Dear readers, when I mention ICE in this article, I'm not referring to shaved ice or an ice cream shop selling soft-serve cones. And no, it's not the "Ice Drinking Studio" of Liang Qichao either… Instead, I'm talking about the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agency—ICE for short.

To call ICE America's enforcement headquarters is no exaggeration—and certainly not an insult. The mere mention of ICE can send shivers down the spine. If your child refuses to go to bed at night, just mention ICE, and they'll likely be under the covers in seconds. Below, I present three true stories connected to ICE. These events are real, and such scenes unfold in America nearly every day.

Story One: 86-Year-Old French Woman Detained by ICE

An 86-year-old French woman, Marie-Thérèse Helene Ross, who moved to the United States to marry a long-lost love, is currently detained at a U.S. immigration facility. According to her family, ICE did not notify them of her detention, and they only found out after French consular officials visited her.

Her son described the ordeal, saying, "They shackled my mother—hands and feet—as though she were a dangerous criminal. Our priority now is to get her out of that facility and back to France. Given her health, she cannot survive a month in those conditions."

Ross had come to the U.S. in 2025 to rekindle a relationship with a former American serviceman. After reconnecting on social media in 2010, the couple reunited, married, and lived together in Anniston, Alabama. Her husband, a retired veteran, passed away in January 2026, and shortly after, Ross was detained by ICE.

In a statement, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) referred to her as "an illegal alien from France" due to her overstayed visa. Despite the harsh language, DHS assured the public that ICE provided comprehensive healthcare services to detainees. They also urged undocumented immigrants to "self-deport," warning that those who refused would face arrest, removal, and a permanent ban from re-entry.

Story Two: A Soldier's Wife Is Not Immune to ICE Enforcement

The arrest of Ross comes amid growing criticism of ICE's aggressive stance, particularly towards the spouses of active-duty military personnel. In early April 2026, ICE agents arrested Annie Ramos, a Honduran immigrant and the wife of a U.S. Army staff sergeant, at a military base in Louisiana.

Her husband, Staff Sergeant Matthew Blank, was heartbroken by the turn of events. He said, "I never imagined that doing the right thing—registering my wife, getting her a dependent ID, starting her green card application—would end with her being taken away from me in handcuffs."

Ramos had been brought to the U.S. as a toddler, and while she had been living in the country for over 20 years, an immigration judge had issued a deportation order against her in 2005—when she was just 20 months old. In a cruel twist, this dormant order was activated when she applied to adjust her immigration status through her marriage.

Ramos' story highlights the disturbing gap between the legal technicalities of immigration law and the lived reality of individuals. Blank emphasized, “This doesn't make us safer. It undermines military families and betrays our fundamental values.”

Story Three: A Blind Refugee Dies After Being Abandoned in the Cold—Is This Murder by Another Name?

In February 2026, a nearly blind Rohingya refugee from Myanmar, Nurul Amin Shah Alam, was found dead on a Buffalo, New York street after being abandoned by U.S. Border Patrol agents. The Erie County Medical Examiner later ruled his death a homicide, citing hypothermia and dehydration.

Shah Alam, who had been held at Erie County Jail for nearly a year, was released on February 19, 2026. After being briefly detained by U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), ICE agents dropped him off at a restaurant, which was closed at the time. Wearing thin jail-issued clothing, Shah Alam wandered into the freezing night and disappeared.

His body was discovered five days later, frozen in the cold. His family, who had been waiting for his release, was not notified. Officials from CBP and DHS denied any responsibility, claiming that Shah Alam showed no signs of distress at the time of release.

New York state officials were outraged. Governor Kathy Hochul condemned the incident as "cruel and inhumane," calling for full accountability. The case exposed not only ICE's mishandling of vulnerable individuals but also the deep-rooted issues within the U.S. immigration enforcement system.

A Moral Failure with National Security Consequences

These stories illustrate the growing fracture between America's immigration enforcement machinery and the moral obligations the country owes to its own citizens and residents. When the government demands that its soldiers risk their lives in defense of the nation, but then fails to protect their families, the result is not just a moral failure—it's a threat to the nation's security.

In all of these cases, ICE's actions raise critical questions about the balance between enforcement and human rights, leaving a trail of anguish and confusion in its wake. Whether it's detaining an elderly woman, arresting a military spouse, or abandoning a refugee in the cold, the broader issue remains: is ICE really serving the best interests of the American people, or is it becoming a tool of fear and oppression?



You've read it. Now let's talk. Follow us on X.    Editor: Penny Wang 



Latest
Tokyo Condo Supply Hits Record Low as Prices Stay Elevated
China’s $13.8M Seychelles Deal Signals Its Biggest Africa Trade Push Yet
Taiwan's President Can't Get Out — So Why Is Beijing Rolling Out the Welcome Mat?
Taiwan's Foreign Ministry Fought Until the Last Minute — But China Still Killed Lai's Africa Trip
Taiwan Discloses $38.5 Billion Defense Procurement Plan, Air Defense Missiles Top Spending
Czech Prime Minister Denies Government Flight for Senate President's Taiwan Visit
Opinion | Taiwan’s Food Waste Could Fuel Carbon Markets—But Only If the Foundations Are Built First
Poland, Japan Joint Statement Highlights Taiwan Strait Stability for First Time
Taiwan's Control Yuan Stirs Up a Four-Year-Old Scandal—Just Before Its Term Ends
Tim Cook Made Apple a $4 Trillion Empire. Now John Ternus Must Defend It.
First Time Since WWII: Japan to Fire Missiles on Philippine Soil
How China's Pineapple Ban Handed Taiwan a Premium Market in Japan
Opinion | The Layoffs at Meta and Snap Aren't About Costs. They're About Replacing You.
7.5 Magnitude Earthquake Strikes Northeast Japan, 3-Meter Tsunami Warning Issued
Mandelson’s close China and Russia ties raised major red flags. Starmer was warned — yet the vetting scandal still exploded.
Taiwan Adopts 'Made with Taiwan' Strategy as U.S. Reindustrialization Reshapes Supply Chains, Scholar Says
The Bureaucrats Who Felt Betrayed — and the Policymakers Who Didn't: Japan's Divided Response to Premier Cho's WBC Visit
Terry Gou’s Daughter Wins Top FRC Impact Award in U.S.
When a DPP Lawmaker Cries "Spy Bus," the Real Threat Is the Argument Itself
U.S. Navy Seizes Iranian Ship in Gulf of Oman — Will Ceasefire Talks Survive?
Not Labor Shortage, But Wage Suppression: The Dangerous Truth Behind Taiwan’s Indian Worker Plan
Opinion|Trump Threatens to Block Strait of Hormuz – NATO Refuses to Follow, Alliance Cracks Emerge
US Commerce Chief Rejects BYD Entry, Signals Hard Line on Chinese EVs
Opinion | Trump Played Messiah. The Pope Didn't Clap.
Opinion| What Hungary's Political Upheaval Teaches Taiwan's Political Parties
A Chinese Robot Just Went Viral in Europe. It Was Chasing Boars.
Opinion|China’s Secret Play: How the CCP is Meddling in US-Iran Nuclear Talks
Taiwan's Zenithtek Powers Into AI With Blackwell and Venice Wins — 60% Revenue Target in Sight
ANZCham Charity Bike Ride Raises NT$266,000 for Disadvantaged Children in Taiwan's Penghu
Taiwan Slams China-Funded Media for Fake Corruption Smear on Eswatini Ambassador
Trump Shattered the Nuclear Taboo — Now Germany, Japan and South Korea Want the Bomb
TSMC Chairman Calls Intel Formidable — Then Explains Why It Still Can't Catch Up
U.S.-Taiwan Trade Explodes 61% as China Imports Plunge: Trump’s OBBBA Triggers Historic Shift
TSMC Ramps Up 3nm Production Worldwide to Meet Soaring AI Demand, Eyes A14 Chips by 2028
Taiwan's First Mainland-Born Lawmaker Had One Job. She Blew It.
NASA Astronaut Born in Taipei Returns to His Roots for Freedom 250
Taiwan dethrones China atop Japan's tourist spending chart
Taiwan FM Meets New Lithuanian Envoy, Targets Semiconductors, AI, Green Energy and Drones
Taiwan Nuclear Restart: Dry Storage Fix Nuclear Waste? Experts Break It Down
From Cheap Gas to Costly Plastic: The Inconsistencies of Taiwan’s Consumer Policy
Hudson Institute Envoy to KMT: Fix the Arms Bill Before It Derails Cheng's Washington Trip
173 Crew, 26 Ships, One Dangerous Strait — Seoul Cuts a Deal with Iran
Evergrande Founder Hui Ka-yan Pleads Guilty to Fraud in Chinese Court
Taiwan's AI Power Map: 12 Companies Redrawing the Global Tech Order
Even Top-Rated TVBS Can't Hold the Line: The Collapse of Traditional Taiwanese Television